12:18 18 November, 2026Andrea Bartzen, dubbed the “fake Cartier heiress” following a bombshell investigation by New York Magazine, has found herself at the center of another controversy. This time, she was turned away from a New York party celebrating the 25th anniversary of chocolate brand MarieBelle.
According to Page Six, Bartzen attempted to attend the event, held Monday evening at MarieBelle's store on Broome Street, but was denied entry by the organizers.
“She tried to persuade the PR person to let her in, but was turned away,” a source who attended the party told the outlet.
The event was hosted by prominent publicist Nora Lawlor, who confirmed that Bartzen was not on the guest list.
“She just showed up. She wasn't on the guest list, and nobody had invited her,” Lawlor said. However, she added that Bartzen was still given a gift bag. Bartzen asked if she could return later, but her request was denied.
Andrea herself offered a different account of what happened. She claimed she had arrived at the invitation of another guest who wanted to meet with her to discuss business matters. However, the invitation to attend as that person's guest had never been officially confirmed. As a result, Bartzen did not make it into the party but met the woman who had invited her outside the store before leaving.
Following the publication of the report, Bartzen threatened to sue Page Six, accusing the outlet of “journalistic assault.”
Bartzen first attracted widespread attention in March, when New York Magazine published an investigation titled “The Fake Cartier and the Fake Rockefeller.” The article alleged that she had passed herself off as a member of the famous jewelry dynasty, while her former boyfriend, Matthew Tomasko, posed as an heir to the Rockefeller family.
According to the investigation, the pair gained access to exclusive parties in Palm Beach, the Hamptons and other upscale enclaves by inventing stories about their backgrounds and connections to influential families. Bartzen was also accused of organizing charity events for which sponsors contributed thousands of dollars, although the promised donations allegedly never reached the organizations they were intended to benefit.
The investigation further claimed that Bartzen had falsely presented herself as an MIT graduate and embellished her professional business credentials. The publication reported that the Massachusetts Institute of Technology had no record of her having studied there.
Bartzen has previously denied the allegations, describing the article as a commissioned hit piece designed to damage her reputation.
The latest incident at the MarieBelle party has now become another chapter in the controversial saga of a woman who, despite the allegations and exposés, continues to move in wealthy social circles.